Bordeaux vs. Burgundy: A Comprehensive Guide 

An Exploration of France's Premier Wine Regions

The two French wine regions of Bordeaux and Burgundy, both titans in their own right, stand as testaments to how geography and tradition can shape vastly different viticultural identities. Though both regions produce world-class wines, their approaches diverge significantly. For enthusiasts, collectors, and investors alike, understanding the nuances between Bordeaux and Burgundy is essential to navigating the rich landscape of French wines and appreciating the unique character each region brings to the glass.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Location

Bordeaux's proximity to the Atlantic Ocean profoundly shaped its wine culture and global reputation. This optimal location granted the region easy access to maritime trade routes, a crucial factor in the early international recognition of its wines. As Bordeaux's wines reached distant markets centuries ago, a thriving, multi-tiered industry of producers and merchants emerged. The Left Bank, with its superior access to waterways, particularly benefited from this maritime advantage, while the more inland Right Bank experienced these effects to a lesser degree.

In contrast, Burgundy's landlocked position in eastern France led to a markedly different historical trajectory. Despite its rich viticultural heritage, including significant Roman and monastic influences, Burgundy's wines remained less internationally renowned for centuries. The region's isolation from major trade routes hindered widespread recognition until relatively recently. Only with the advent of modern transportation did Burgundy's exceptional wines gain global acclaim. This late bloom in international markets hasn't hindered Burgundy's ascent; today, many of its wines command stratospheric prices, often surpassing even Bordeaux's most prestigious offerings.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Climate

The climatic conditions of each region have played a pivotal role in shaping their distinctive wine styles. Bordeaux boasts a maritime climate influenced by the Atlantic Ocean and the Gironde estuary. This moderating effect creates ideal conditions for late-ripening varieties like Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot. In contrast, Burgundy nestles in the heart of eastern France, with a continental climate characterized by hot summers and cold winters. Here, the capricious Pinot Noir and Chardonnay grapes thrive, producing wines of ethereal finesse.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Soil Types

The two regions' divergent geologies further accentuate their differences. Bordeaux's Left Bank is dominated by gravelly soils, perfect for draining excess water and stressing vines to produce concentrated fruit. The Right Bank features more clay and limestone, ideal for Merlot's water-retention needs. Burgundy's hallmark is its limestone-rich soils, interspersed with marl and clay, which impart a distinctive minerality to its wines.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Grape Varieties

These geological distinctions manifest in the grape varieties cultivated. Bordeaux reds are typically blends, featuring Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, and Malbec as the primary players. Burgundy, in contrast, stakes its reputation on single-varietal wines, with Pinot Noir dominating the reds and Chardonnay the whites. However, Burgundy's viticultural landscape is more diverse than it first appears. The region also boasts two other historically significant grapes: the white Aligoté and the red Gamay. Both are typically bottled as single-varietal wines, with Gamay playing a starring role in Beaujolais, Burgundy's expansive southernmost region.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Red Wine Styles

In the glass, Bordeaux reds typically exhibit a fuller body, higher tannins, and more prominent oak influence. Notes of blackcurrant, cedar, and graphite are common, with Left Bank wines leaning towards austerity and power, while Right Bank offerings often show more supple, plummy characteristics. Burgundian Pinot Noir, by contrast, offers a lighter body with higher acidity, showcasing red fruit flavors, earthy undertones, and a silky texture that can be positively haunting in its complexity.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: White Wine Styles

White wines from these regions are equally distinct. Bordeaux produces dry whites primarily from Sauvignon Blanc and Sémillon, resulting in crisp, herbaceous wines with a hint of tropical fruit. The region is also home to Sauternes, whose botrytis-affected grapes yield some of the world's most luxurious sweet wines. Burgundian Chardonnay, whether from Chablis in the north or the Côte d'Or further south, offers a spectrum from lean and flinty to rich and buttery, always underpinned by that characteristic Burgundian minerality.

Classification Systems: Châteaux vs. Terroir

The contrasting histories of Bordeaux and Burgundy are mirrored in their distinct classification systems. Bordeaux's early global prominence, particularly on the Left Bank, is reflected in the enduring 1855 Classification system, which has been a cornerstone of the region's wine industry for over 150 years. Even the Right Bank, though later to the game, established its own classification for St-Émilion in the mid-20th century.

These Bordeaux systems primarily revolve around the châteaux and their holdings, emphasizing brand recognition and estate reputation. This approach stands in stark contrast to Burgundy's philosophy. The Burgundian classification system, developed much later, focuses on specific vineyard plots rather than producers. This intricate system of appellations elevates the concept of terroir above all else, highlighting the unique characteristics of each parcel of land.

This fundamental difference in classification approaches reflects the regions' distinct historical developments and market positioning. While Bordeaux's system reinforces its tradition of château-driven prestige, Burgundy's method underscores its emphasis with the nuanced expression of place.

Bordeaux vs Burgundy: Bottle Shape

Even the bottles themselves tell a tale of divergence, their shapes evolving over centuries to reflect each region's unique needs and traditions. Bordeaux's distinctive bottle, with its high shoulders, straight sides, and narrow base, was primarily designed for easy stacking during sea transport. This shape, however, serves a dual purpose: the prominent shoulders and tapered body are particularly effective at catching sediment, a common occurrence in tannin-rich Bordeaux wines as they age.

In contrast, Burgundy bottles feature gently sloping shoulders and a wider base, a design that likely originated from practicality rather than necessity. This curved shape was simply easier for early glassmakers to create, and it suited the region's more localized distribution needs. Over time, these distinct bottle shapes have become iconic, instantly signaling the wine's origin to connoisseurs worldwide.

The Enduring Allure of both Bordeaux & Burgundy

Bordeaux and Burgundy, though rivals in reputation, collectively showcase the pinnacle of French winemaking. Their contrasts—from robust blends to delicate single-varietals—offer a compelling study in terroir's influence. Whether drawn to Bordeaux's power or Burgundy's finesse, wine enthusiasts find in both regions an inexhaustible source of discovery, each bottle a testament to centuries of viticultural mastery.

Join our VIP mailing list

Join our VIP mailing list to get 5% OFF your first purchase, receive VIP Offerings, and more!